A new supplement to the Australian Human Rights Commission’s 2024 ‘Help Way Earlier!’ report released this month explores opportunities to reform Australia’s child and youth justice system.

The 2025 report outlines six new case studies highlighting successful and promising evidence-based approaches to youth justice reform from across the world and Australia. It builds on the 2024 report’s emphasis on the importance of addressing children’s baseline needs.

National Children’s Commissioner Anne Hollonds says crime by children is a symptom of their unmet needs and underlying issues that we are currently failing to address.

“Protecting their rights, safety and wellbeing doesn’t get in the way of community safety as is sometimes claimed – it’s actually the most effective way of preventing crime in the long run,” she says.

The report found punitive justice measures, including detention and imprisonment, can have lasting traumatic and harmful effects on children and young people. In Australia, current practices are found to be ineffective deterrents, with 70% returning within six months of release, and 84% within twelve.

As such, these case studies have been identified as approaches that will work and have the potential to positively transform Australia’s child and youth justice system – focusing on early intervention, community partnership and system-wide reform to better meet the needs of children. The case studies reinforce the importance of prevention-focused strategies to reduce youth reoffending rates and improve child safety and wellbeing.

Case Studies:

  1. Scotland: Whole System Approach

A national strategy aiming to prevent children’s contact with the justice system through early intervention and diversion. This approach takes a holistic, rights-based, cross-government, participatory focus on prevention and support.

  1. Queensland, Australia: Pathways to Prevention

A Pilot program supporting early intervention through positive childhood development. By building local partnerships, community informed care, and harnessing the help of educational institutions and data – the program identifies local challenges and responds early in a child’s developmental years.

Pathways to Prevention emphasises small scale, local-focussed initiatives implemented community wide – ensuring all children are addressed.

  1. Walgett, New South Wales, Australia: Baulaarr Bagay Warruwi Burranba-li-gu (Two River Pathway to Change)

An aboriginal led, place based and community driven approach to self-determination, empowerment and culturally informed responses. The program centres the belonging, safety and wellbeing of children, tackling community-specific issues through the active involvement of families, carers and support networks. This works to foster community participation and cultural engagement in young people and children.

  1. Netherlands, Missouri (USA), Spain: Community Based and Therapeutic Approaches

These programs harness small scale, community integrated alternatives to detention. They prioritise local accessibility, flexibility and therapeutic environments tailored to young people’s needs and addressing baseline issues.

Key Takeaways for Australia’s child and youth justice system:

  • Position children and families at the centre of all reform and policy service design
  • Invest in early-intervention and primary-prevention programs
  • Empower communities through long term, culturally responsive and collaborative involvement
  • Align government initiatives and policy to support local programs and initiatives
  • Integrate First Nations perspectives and consultation in program delivery to support and empower local communities
  • Engage in continuous improvement practices, collecting data and analysing what works and what doesn’t to inform future practice
  • Collaborate across sectors to identify key needs of children and young people to inform early intervention measures

Related articles

Last updated: 11 Nov 2025