Looking for positives amongst recurring disasters
For individuals and families who have suffered loss and dislocation, it is hard to find positives amid frequent and intense natural disasters. There are green shoots however in the systems that support effective response and recovery. Here are three emerging positives and ways in which each can, indeed must, be developed further.
10 Mar 2026
In this Perspectives article, David Tennant, Tatura Projects, explores how we can further develop systems and support for families during natural disasters.
A few years ago, it seemed everyone in a public leadership role was issuing warnings about getting used to more frequent and intense natural disasters. Those warnings have slowed. There is reduced effect in alerting people to a potential that is already occurring. Natural disasters with devastating impact have become almost routine.
For individuals and families who have suffered loss and dislocation, it is hard to find positives. There are green shoots however in the systems that support effective response and recovery. Here are three emerging positives and ways in which each can, indeed must, be developed further.
Coordinating immediate support
The increased frequency of natural disasters has focused the need for prompt response and information. The Victorian Government has general information available all the time, to help people prepare. More detailed, tailored resources often go live even before new events are complete and are updated in real time. That is a huge step-forward in a short period.
There is recognition that needs land in stages, from actions that make communities and properties safe to return to, through to ongoing casework support delivered by contracted community providers. This now feels like a system, not a series of separate, event-based activities.
There is room to develop further. For example, recognition that some will need direct help with and resourcing for clean-up, is great. The criteria for determining who will get that help, how much and how quickly, is less clear. Government does not have to shoulder all the responsibility, or cost, but it should lead proactively. There are similar issues with eligibility for and access to reestablishment grants.
We must also remember that putting everything online does not provide assurance the messages reach the people who need them most. That can include people who struggle with technology, or with language barriers. The infrastructure that delivers mobile and online communications can and does get impacted by natural disasters as well.
Acknowledging the importance of place
References to place-based planning and response appear throughout the emergency and disaster policies of all levels of government. Practical effect and real understanding are more than being able to find a place on a map, but there is a welcome and increasingly genuine appreciation of the value of service and support being provided within communities, wherever possible.
Local support is more than just the potential of a familiar face. Our state has widely variable geography, with implications for safe, physical access. That can play out in a range of ways. Everything from whether it is possible to reach an isolated household, to providing vouchers for a shop in an impacted community, not a big supermarket 100 km away.
The next stage of development should increase the opportunities for trust in commissioning steps. All entities receiving public funds must be accountable, but cooperation is more important than competition in providing effective local support.
Reframing the approach to risk
There is a clearer and increasingly shared understanding that traditional models for identifying and insuring risk are approaching their use-by date. The changes have been evolving for a while but have accelerated dramatically since the scorched summer of 2019/2020 immediately before the pandemic.
Recognition that large and expanding areas are, or will soon be uninsurable, is changing the conversation about planning and building standards. As insurance options are withdrawn or are priced in ways that produce the same result, the cost for the remainder of the market changes as well. There will likely be a viability tipping point and with what used to be described as 100-year events occurring in successive seasons, it may not be far away. Now is the time for considering options and alternatives, rather than waiting for failure.
Governments, industry, experts in a range of fields from climatology to engineering to alternative models for sharing risk and many in between, can help communities understand what is happening and invite their input. Complex issues are frequently hidden from view until announcements are ready to be made. The best public policy development brings the public along.
Related articles
Last updated: 10 Mar 2026