Scarcely a day goes by without at least one media report on youth crime. The offences described are invariably antisocial, frequently violent, and occasionally tragic.

There is a concerning trend of organised gangs recruiting highly vulnerable young people to commit serious crimes for money.

For victims of crimes committed by children and young people, including home invasions, vicious assaults, carjacking, theft, and arson, the impact can be profound and lifelong.

Life-changing injuries and ever-present fear can transform everyday living. In the worst of cases, youth crime has resulted in loss of life and permanent anguish for family members of the victims.

Responses from the community generally favour strong punishment, including detention and no bail. Responses from experts generally call for more investment in addressing the drivers of youth crime and reducing recidivism.

These are not mutually exclusive things, as so often implied in the media.

Enabling children to grow up in safe and stable environments, connecting them to their culture and community, can help keep the wider community safe by preventing crime before it starts.

For children already caught up in the justice system, linking them into services – to diagnose developmental delay or disability, improve literacy and mental health, address substance misuse, manage anger, provide life skills, engage in education or training, provide employment – can help turn their lives around and reduce re-offending.

Across Australia, there is a patchwork of different jurisdictional responses to youth crime. The age at which a child is judged criminally responsible for their actions differs across the country.

In 2024, the former National Children’s Commissioner, Dr Anne Hollonds, released her ‘Help way earlier’ report on Australia’s child justice system.

The report identified the many systems and approaches which have failed children, particularly Aboriginal children. Her report is unequivocal – locking up children does not make the community safer.

Little has changed since her report, despite the evidence underpinning her recommendations. We still have no national leadership on child justice reform; no coordinated, national approach to prevention or diversion.

Without national leadership young people will continue to be caught up in systems that are reactive and punitive, rather than focused on prevention, healing and long-term community safety.

The Victorian Government has adopted a two-pronged approach to youth crime. On the one hand, in an election year, it is demonstrating its tough stance on youth crime through implementation of new ‘adult time for adult crime’ laws.

On the other hand, it is investing significantly in a Violence Reduction Unit which takes a much more evidenced approach to addressing the root causes of youth crime. The VRU recognises that youth crime does not occur in a vacuum. It is driven by poverty, trauma, disengagement from education, and a lack of access to support.

These two approaches are being delivered alongside each other. Of the two, the evidence leans towards the preventative response making a difference in children’s lives rather than criminalisation and detention.

Addressing the factors which lead children to engage in criminal activities does not mean being soft on crime. For a community to be safe, we need to invest in reform that keeps children safe from harm, safe from older predators seeking to exploit their youth, preventing immersion into crime before it begins, and supporting children to make sound decisions as they mature.

The Commonwealth plays a critical role in driving national consistency and reform and investing in evidence-led programs. The ‘Help way earlier’ report called for a National Taskforce for reform of child justice systems and provided a way forward with its recommendations.

This issue is urgent if we are to keep children and communities safe from harm.

 

 

Related articles

Last updated: 01 Jul 2026