Adult time is no solution for children says peak
The Centre for Excellence in Child and Family Welfare has joined community organisations across Victoria in expressing dismay at the Victorian Government’s ‘Adult Time for Violent Crime’ youth justice changes.
25 Nov 2025
The Centre for Excellence in Child and Family Welfare has joined community organisations across Victoria in expressing dismay at the Victorian Government’s ‘Adult Time for Violent Crime’ youth justice changes.
As the peak body for child and family services in Victoria, the Centre is deeply concerned by an approach to child offending that is not consistent with international evidence about child development and human rights.
Under the proposed changes, children aged 14 and above who commit violent crimes will face adult sentences in adult courts.
The Centre’s Interim CEO, Dr Michele Lonsdale, said the government needs a more balanced approach that prioritises community safety while also allowing for nuanced, evidence-backed responses that tackle the root causes of youth offending.
The overwhelming evidence – in Australia and internationally – shows that incarcerating children increases the frequency and severity of offending. Approaches that are “tough on crime” have consistently failed across jurisdictions and generations. This approach does not deter crime; it entrenches it.
Dr Lonsdale said the focus must be on addressing the root causes of youth crime, before children become caught up in spiralling offending. It should be on early intervention to support families, meaningful rehabilitation when a child does offend, and community support.
She welcomed last week’s announcement of a Violence Reduction Unit, which will place social workers in 20 targeted schools to support children who are heading down the wrong path, but stresses that much more investment is needed if we are to change children’s lives.
“We know what works, and locking children up from as young as 14 is not a constructive solution. These measures provide no lasting benefit to the community, the young person, or their wider family or friendship group,” she said.
“We need the evidence-led interventions to divert children who are struggling and drifting toward crime and violent behaviours. We should be looking at initiatives which we know from international evidence will have significant success in reducing violent crime among younger age groups and keep communities safe,” said Dr Lonsdale.
“Legislating a life sentence option for children who have offended is punishing them for the circumstances of their lives, which have left them disengaged from school and community supports and vulnerable to being preyed upon by older criminals.”
Dr Lonsdale said the Centre supports an approach that does not give up on children.
“We look forward to working with the Victorian Government to invest in proven early intervention and diversion programs to give our kids the best chance possible to turn their lives around so that communities can be safe,” she said.
ENDS
Related articles
Last updated: 25 Nov 2025